Ján Štuller: We do not want to avoid a tender for Dukovany and Temelín. We are not taking the Hungarian route

The Czech Republic is not currently considering taking inspiration from Hungary, which agreed directly with Russia's Rosatom to build new nuclear reactors – without a tender. “The Czech Republic wants a competition,” confirmed Ján Štuller, the government's commissioner for nuclear energy, in the second part of an interview with oEnergetice, adding that there is complete consensus on this issue.
According to Štuller, all six foreign bidders for the construction of reactors in the Czech Republic have expressed a willingness, if necessary, to take equity stakes in ČEZ subsidiaries that would be responsible for building new reactors at Dukovany and Temelín. These foreign bidders are Atmea (a French-Japanese venture), CGN (China), EDF (France), KHNP (Korea), Rosatom (Russia) and Westinghouse (USA).
The government commissioner also said that a large team of experts would work on formulating requirements for suppliers of the new Czech reactors. The Czech list of characteristics that a latest-generation 3+ reactor should have may be quite original – it could also include a basic idea of the optimal price for such a reactor.
(The first part of the interview with Ján Štuller can be found here.)
What specific requirements will the Czech Republic have for new nuclear reactors at Dukovany or Temelín? In the previously cancelled Temelín tender, there was a requirement that these should be generation 3+, or three-and-a-half generation, nuclear reactors. Not merely third-generation reactors. Will this also apply in the next tender, which could involve six foreign interested parties?
Last year, we asked all ten originally approached foreign companies to state the basic technical characteristics of their reactors that correspond to generation 3+. In other words, to say whether the type of reactor they offer is generation 3+ or not. On the other hand, although we have our own ideas, we do not have any precise definition of what generation 3+ is. There is no encyclopaedia in which this is precisely described, nor is there an exact international definition enshrined in any agreements. There is no internationally defined and recognised clear boundary between what belongs to generation 3 and what belongs to generation 3+.
So do you want to create such a definition for the purposes of the planned tender?
To a certain extent, yes. Above all, we want to confirm a list of features, characteristics and parameters that are typical of the different generations – especially the third generation, generation 3+, and possibly the future fourth generation. During the tender, we will then look at how each reactor type meets the respective characteristics. Individual reactor types come closer to these various characteristics to differing degrees. No reactor is clearly the best in every respect. These are different reactor concepts. All potential bidders state that they offer generation 3 or 3+ reactors. We will conduct a detailed analysis of this during the competition.
Could you already mention examples of technical characteristics that distinguish generation 3+ from pure third generation?
These are primarily technical characteristics and parameters relating to reactor safety. In this regard, generation 3+ is particularly shaped by post-Fukushima measures. Some colleagues in the sector say that the entire generation 3+ concept is merely a marketing gimmick. My view is that generation 3+ is characterised by the ability to operate for a longer period and, in particular, to ensure reactor nuclear safety in island mode, i.e. if everything possible in the vicinity of the plant fails. An important requirement, for example, is for the so-called ultimate heat sink to be able to remove residual heat produced by the reactor after shutdown for at least thirty days. I am convinced that we must place emphasis on a greater extent of passive safety systems and greater plant resilience to external impacts, whether natural or caused by human activity. We are also considering defining economic and reliability parameters.
So, an economic characteristic of generation 3+?
That would be a Czech peculiarity; perhaps we could contribute to defining generation 3+ from this perspective as well. In principle, we would stipulate that reactors should be relatively inexpensive and feature an optimal ratio between price, including operating costs, and quality. However, we are only discussing the configuration of individual characteristics so far; this is purely brainstorming. We will see what we arrive at.
Translation disclaimer
This article is a machine translation of the Czech original and has not yet been fully reviewed. In case of any doubt, please refer to the Czech version.
The article continues for subscribers
Premium content
The rest of this article is available to premium subscribers only. Get access to all premium articles on oEnergetice.cz.
You have read only 31% of the article — unlock the remaining 69% with a premium subscription.
Best value: annual subscription
Monthly option 4 € / month
3.25 €/ month




