Nuclear power plant flexibility – an opportunity for nuclear advocates?

Jan Žižka
5 June 2018, 18:04
Nuclear power plant flexibility – an opportunity for nuclear advocates?

Tilting at windmills. Today, we could replace this phrase with “fighting renewable energy sources”. It is clear that such a fight is lost from the outset. Renewables are taking an ever larger slice of the “pie” – the energy mix. Around the world.

Yet even proponents of green energy are increasingly recognising that the idea of a 100% transition to renewables is, in the foreseeable future, nothing more than a utopia. And so “green” thinking is taking another direction: Which other source will gain the privilege of accompanying the sun, wind, water and biomass in their victorious advance?

Paradoxically, in the minds of many advocates of low-carbon energy, this privilege is being granted to a fossil fuel – natural gas, which can flexibly and rapidly balance the weather dependence of photovoltaic and wind power plants. Germany’s “real green policy”, however, has so far actually favoured a source with substantially higher greenhouse gas emissions – conventional coal.

According to a number of renewable energy advocates, zero-emission nuclear power is entirely out of the game. It is allegedly an inflexible source that can operate only at base load and cannot adapt to the new energy system. From the perspective of nuclear advocates, however, this is a myth. Technically speaking, nuclear power plants can already adjust their output today. France, for example, has entirely practical experience with this. And requirements for the flexibility and “manoeuvrability” of new nuclear power plants are increasing.

Representatives of the nuclear industry and power sector are therefore becoming increasingly vocal. They argue that, in terms of emissions, nuclear power as a clean source is the best possible partner for renewable energy. Not all advocates of nuclear power, or conventional power plants more broadly, are pleased with this argument. In effect, it represents too great a concession to renewables, as if the only question were how other sources can adapt to them. Proponents of a “balanced” energy system argue that considerations should be based on assessing all the strengths and weaknesses of individual sources, their application under specific conditions, and then determining an appropriate mix.

Foratom speaks up

One way or another, the fact is that developments are gradually moving towards ever greater flexibility at nuclear power plants. Foratom, the Brussels-based association of the European nuclear energy industry, recently highlighted this in its Position Paper.

“Despite the widespread perception of nuclear power plants as inflexible baseload sources, nuclear energy can in fact provide, on a large scale, a solution to the need for flexibility and grid stability in some Member States,” Foratom said.

Foratom further stresses that nuclear power is the main partner of renewables when it comes to decarbonisation within the European Union. The association recalls that nuclear power now provides 27 % of electricity in the EU and nearly 50 % of its low-carbon electricity. Nuclear advocates (not only from Foratom) also point out that it will not be possible even to come close to meeting the Paris climate agreement without nuclear power plants. In another paper last year, Foratom stated that the targets of the EU’s so-called winter package cannot be met without nuclear power, and that achieving Europe’s commitment to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by more than 80 percent by 2050 (compared with 1990 levels) is likewise unrealistic.

63 MW per minute

The Brussels association calculates that, for new nuclear reactors, it will become entirely standard to reduce or increase output by 5 percent of total capacity per minute when needed. It is also taken for granted that reactor output will range from 50 to 100 percent of maximum capacity. This was also recently stated by Zalán Bács, head of Rosatom in Hungary, when speaking about the planned construction of new units at the Paks nuclear power plant.

“This is no longer merely baseload; Generation III+ reactors can genuinely respond to the requirements of the transmission system,” Bács said at the Pro-Energy Forum conference in Pezinok, Slovakia. He expects this manoeuvrability to be used in practice.

Converting this into specific figures, Foratom gave the example in its paper of a reactor with installed capacity of 1260 megawatts. Its output can therefore range between 630 and 1260 megawatts, while output can be changed at a rate of plus or minus 63 megawatts per minute.

France and the Czech Republic

Translation disclaimer

This article is a machine translation of the Czech original and has not yet been fully reviewed. In case of any doubt, please refer to the Czech version.

The article continues for subscribers

Premium content

The rest of this article is available to premium subscribers only. Get access to all premium articles on oEnergetice.cz.

You have read only 45% of the article — unlock the remaining 55% with a premium subscription.

Best value: annual subscription

Monthly option 4 € / month

3.25 €/ month

I already have a subscription