Trump wages “war” on energy research. Is he helping China?

Jan Žižka
14 August 2017, 17:14
Trump wages “war” on energy research. Is he helping China?

For more than 70 years, the United States government has been the strongest driver of scientific progress in energy. These are the words of one of the world’s most respected energy analysts, Daniel Yergin, in his book The Quest. Today, voices are increasingly being heard saying that the Trump administration will put an end to this and significantly reduce spending on energy research.

According to his fiercest critics, President Donald Trump has even declared a “war on science”, also an allusion to his earlier claims that he would end the “war on coal”. What is certain is that America now faces major wrangling over the future research budget – especially energy research. While the administration has proposed major cuts (in the case of energy research, $3.1 billion, or 18 percent), the House of Representatives advocates a smaller reduction, while the Senate is the most generous towards US scientists in this respect and is pushing for a modest budget increase.

Moreover, this is not just about the future budget: federal research spending is already actually declining. During the first seven months of this year, it fell by 16 percent overall compared with the same period last year.

In addition to the proposed overall cuts in research spending, the term “war on science” also relates to doubts among the current rulers in Washington about the need to confront global climate change. This is in turn having a negative impact primarily on research related to “green” technologies, renewable sources and energy savings. Paradoxically, however, the proposed cuts also affect research into nuclear power and fossil fuels, albeit to a lesser extent. Budget savings appear to be the priority, with scepticism over the state’s role in supporting research and development in the background.

Czech interest, Chinese hopes

The outcome of the battle over US government funding for energy research may also matter from a Czech perspective. Energy is among the most important areas of Czech-US cooperation in research and development. Particularly promising, for example, is cooperation on developing small modular reactors between the Research Centre Řež and Oak Ridge National Laboratory, a leading US laboratory which, like 16 others, falls under the US Department of Energy.

While Donald Trump speaks of the need to strengthen US dominance in global energy (in his view, mainly through producing and exporting oil, gas and coal), his critics fear that he is doing precisely the opposite. They say his approach to energy research is effectively playing into China’s hands. Chinese companies and universities are reportedly already circling US research projects and start-ups, offering to provide them with the funding they need.

According to The Washington Post, Alexander Girau, the founder and CEO of Advano, a company developing silicon-based materials, has received similar offers. These materials could significantly improve battery performance. Advano lost a US Department of Energy grant despite its partnership with a national laboratory and a university. And Chinese investors are offering to buy a stake in the company. Girau himself is convinced that China is now making enormous progress in research and innovation.

Translation disclaimer

This article is a machine translation of the Czech original and has not yet been fully reviewed. In case of any doubt, please refer to the Czech version.

The article continues for subscribers

Premium content

The rest of this article is available to premium subscribers only. Get access to all premium articles on oEnergetice.cz.

You have read only 35% of the article — unlock the remaining 65% with a premium subscription.

Best value: annual subscription

Monthly option 4 € / month

3.25 €/ month

I already have a subscription