Twilight of European nuclear power? Koreans disagree, seek partners in Czechia

Jan Žižka
3 October 2016, 19:30
Twilight of European nuclear power? Koreans disagree, seek partners in Czechia

The past belonged to the Americans and the French; the future belongs to the Chinese, Russians and Koreans. Such a view of the future of nuclear power is certainly not unusual today. Europe is grappling with two cautionary examples of the construction of new-generation nuclear reactors at Flamanville in France and Olkiluoto in Finland, both of which are suffering major delays and cost overruns, while preparations for a number of other projects have stalled. Germany is abandoning nuclear power altogether.

Yet it is the Chinese, Russians and Koreans who, paradoxically, refuse to write off European nuclear power. Korean ambitions in Europe may have received the least attention so far. But the country’s energy company KEPCO is increasingly signalling its interest. In London and other European capitals, including Prague.

And the state-controlled company KEPCO has a significant advantage: if the Russians are barred from somewhere for political reasons and Chinese expansion continues to run into security concerns, none of this applies to the South Koreans.

The British test

Britain recently learned of the current Korean interest. The British press published information according to which KEPCO is in talks to join the NuGen consortium, which plans to build three new reactors at the Moorside power plant in Cumbria, northern England.

The Koreans would thus join Japan’s Toshiba and French company Engie. The reactors for the Moorside plant are to be supplied by a Toshiba subsidiary – the US company Westinghouse, well known in Czechia.

The question is whether the Koreans are trying to emulate the Chinese strategy in Britain: first joining as co-investors, then offering their own reactors. The Koreans would certainly be more appealing to many people in the United Kingdom: while the new British government of Theresa May began to take a cautious approach towards Chinese plans and delayed the project for another (and so far better-known) power plant, Hinkley Point, with French-Chinese investors. It only gave this project the go-ahead after reportedly receiving assurances that the Chinese could not control the entire project themselves.

It began with a victory over the French

Preliminary design of the two new EPR reactor units to be built alongside Magnox and AGR reactors.
Preliminary design of Hinkley Point C – two new EPR reactor units to be built alongside Magnox and AGR reactors. Source: EDF Energy

The Koreans now have ambitions to join a project which, if necessary, could perhaps become a kind of alternative to the controversial Hinkley Point, where the same French EPR reactors as at Flamanville and Olkiluoto are eventually to be built.

It may seem symbolic that KEPCO’s entire major push into international markets began seven years ago precisely with a victory over the traditional ruler of European nuclear power – French company Areva. The US-Japanese joint venture GE Hitachi was also among the losers.

This happened in 2009, when the Koreans won the tender for four reactors at the Barakah power plant in the United Arab Emirates. The French, convinced of the perfection of their EPR reactor, took the defeat very badly.

A springboard to the world

Conversely, the Barakah project, where KEPCO also works closely with Americans (who act as subcontractors there), is set to become a Korean springboard for the large-scale export of Korean APR 1400 reactors around the world. The partnership with the Koreans could perhaps be embodied by manager Tom Samson, who was in the management of the nuclear company Emirates Nuclear Energy Corporation and now heads the NuGen consortium in Britain.

South Korea has set a target of becoming the world’s third-largest exporter of nuclear reactors by 2030. It starts from a strong domestic base, as one of the world’s leading operators of nuclear power plants – in addition to 24 existing reactors with a total capacity of almost 22 gigawatts, the Koreans are building another six on home soil. They are also already planning the construction of four more units.

Following in Rosatom’s footsteps?

Korean activities abroad resemble the strategy of concluding preliminary agreements pursued by Russian state corporation Rosatom. KEPCO recently signed a memorandum of understanding with Kenya, covering not only the construction of future power plants but also the exchange of experience – in effect, assistance with developing Kenya’s nuclear programme.

However, it would be a mistake to paint South Korea’s peaceful nuclear programme entirely rosy; this advanced country has also faced critical moments. Three years ago, the country was hit by a major scandal when the nuclear regulator discovered that suppliers of components for its reactors had forged thousands of safety certificates.

The prospect of Dukovany

Translation disclaimer

This article is a machine translation of the Czech original and has not yet been fully reviewed. In case of any doubt, please refer to the Czech version.

The article continues for subscribers

Premium content

The rest of this article is available to premium subscribers only. Get access to all premium articles on oEnergetice.cz.

Best value: annual subscription

Monthly option 4 € / month

3.25 €/ month

I already have a subscription